top of page

Brownsville Charter Amendments: Commission Canvasses the Vote, Approves Carlton Drive Duplexes 4-3

1 day ago
11 min read
Veterans receive a Veterans Day proclamation from the Brownsville City Commission at the front of the commission chambers on Nov. 17, 2026, with the proclamation text shown on screen.
Brownsville City Commission, Nov. 17, 2026. Frame from the City of Brownsville's public meeting video.

BROWNSVILLE, Texas - The Brownsville charter amendments are one vote from being official. At its Nov. 17, 2026 canvassing and regular meeting, the City Commission heard the vote totals for the charter propositions from the Nov. 3 special election read into the record and approved the canvass ordinance on first reading. Second reading is set for Dec. 1.


The same night, a divided commission advanced a rezoning for two duplexes on each of two lots at the entrance to Carlton Drive, a 1950s neighborhood off Boca Chica Boulevard, after several residents asked members to keep it single-family. The vote, as announced at the meeting, was 4-3.


The commission also approved a permit for a CarMax used-car dealership on Stillman Road, a 112-lot duplex plan on Texas Starway Street, and a $1.35 million fire engine on the consent agenda.


The 956 Report reviewed the city's meeting video and the posted agenda and packet. The meeting was streamed in two parts on the city's YouTube channel. Items that could not be confirmed are noted below.



Video: City of Brownsville, City Commission Meeting, Nov. 17, 2026, in two parts (part 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9zGtuwjcZM8 ; part 2, above, about 3 hours, 11 minutes). The meeting was called to order shortly after 5 p.m. in the Commission Chambers at City Hall - Old Federal Building, 1001 E. Elizabeth St. The commission went into executive session at 7:02 p.m., returned at 8:25 p.m. and adjourned at 8:26 p.m.


THE BROWNSVILLE CHARTER AMENDMENTS, BY THE NUMBERS


What it means for you: These are the charter changes voters approved Nov. 3. They become part of the City Charter only after the commission finishes the canvass and enters the order declaring them adopted. Under the posted ordinance, that is Ordinance 2026-1834, with second and final reading scheduled for Dec. 1.


A city staff member read into the record the results provided by the county that administered the election, which staff described as unofficial. All 14 propositions read aloud passed. The figures below are as read at the meeting, and the percentages are The 956 Report's arithmetic:


  • A (automatic forfeiture of office, including for missing meetings): 37,036 for, 2,692 against (93.2%).

  • B (recall election after certain convictions found to involve moral turpitude): 36,323 for, 3,061 against (92.2%).

  • C (candidates and officeholders cannot be delinquent on city taxes or debts): 33,587 for, 5,332 against (86.3%).

  • D (pay of $62,500 a year for the mayor and $50,000 for commissioners, only for people first elected after the amendment takes effect): 25,537 for, 12,708 against (66.8%).

  • E (city secretary office defined in the charter): 35,093 for, 3,701 against (90.5%).

  • F (city auditor office): 34,329 for, 4,000 against (89.6%).

  • G (merit hiring): 32,166 for, 5,674 against (85.0%).

  • H (Audit and Oversight Committee grows from five to seven members): 29,102 for, 8,833 against (76.7%).

  • I (the audit committee can hire outside auditors): 31,385 for, 7,079 against (81.6%).

  • J (local campaign finance rules): 34,777 for, 3,430 against (91.0%).

  • K (ethics code and ethics board): 34,581 for, 3,447 against (90.9%).

  • L (citizen initiative petitions): 31,144 for, 6,064 against (83.7%).

  • M (citizen referendum petitions): 31,409 for, 5,561 against (85.0%).

  • N ("Brownsville First Jobs & Contracts Policy"): 34,941 for, 2,972 against (92.2%).


Proposition D was the closest. The Brownsville Herald has reported that the mayor is paid $40,000 a year and commissioners $25,000 now. Under the ballot language in the packet, the raise does not apply to members currently in office.


The agenda lists 15 propositions, A through O. Proposition O, which cleans up provisions superseded by state law and outdated wording in Articles I through VII (except Article VI, Utilities Board), was not read aloud during the meeting. The Brownsville Herald, citing unofficial results, reported that all 15 propositions passed. The 956 Report has not yet confirmed the official Proposition O totals.


No one spoke at the public hearing. The ordinance passed on first reading. The vote was announced as 7-0.


CARLTON DRIVE: A 4-3 VOTE OVER NEIGHBORS' OBJECTIONS


What it means for you: The rezoning is on first reading only. It still needs a second and final vote, and a site plan and permits would come later.


The request (Ordinance 235-2026-025) rezones Lots 1 and 2 of the Carlton Subdivision, at 1 and 20 Carlton Drive on the corner of Boca Chica Boulevard, from single-family (R-1) to Residential Transition (R-3), to allow two duplexes on each lot. Planning staff said the parking would face Carlton Drive, with no access from Boca Chica.


Staff said a 2021-22 request for these lots, which also included a commercial plaza, was denied by the commission on Jan. 18, 2022. Staff said the current owners are different and the plaza is no longer part of the plan. City staff and the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval.


Staff said its calculation put opposition at 31% within the legal notice area, which did not trigger a supermajority vote. Staff said that under a recent state law, House Bill 24, "certain super majority requirements were shifted and increased to 60%, when back a year ago it was 20% meaning that tonight a super majority vote will not be required by this commission."


Several Carlton Drive residents spoke against the request. They talked about flooding when it rains, sewer backups, traffic turning onto Boca Chica, and keeping the street's character. One resident, who said she is a nurse, told the commission, "Our opposition comes down to basic safety." Another said 12 of the 14 owners within the 200-foot notice area signed a petition against the change, and cited 1952 deed restrictions. The 956 Report has not reviewed that petition or the deed restrictions. A homeowner next to one of the lots said, "We're not against Brownsville growing."


Asked about drainage on the street, City Engineer Carlos Lastra said crews would start work, hopefully that week. He said the city is "actually planning to regrade those ditches and send it to the resaca towards the rear and improve that area to help alleviate that drainage concern," and estimated it would take two to three weeks. A commissioner asked him to follow up with the Brownsville Public Utilities Board about the size of the sewer lines.


A motion to deny the rezoning failed on a roll call that took several tries to settle. A motion to approve then passed. The vote was announced as 4-3. Each member's vote on the final motion could not be confirmed from the meeting video, so The 956 Report is not listing them here.


SAM PERL BOULEVARD: A WAREHOUSE, BUT NOT LIGHT INDUSTRIAL ZONING


The owner of Lot 3, AA Brownsville Ltd. Subdivision, at 15 Sam Perl Blvd. asked to rezone from R-3 to Light Industrial for a medical-equipment logistics and distribution warehouse. Planning staff recommended denial. They said the request conflicts with the comprehensive plan and the new downtown master plan, even though Planning and Zoning had recommended approval. "If this does not materialize, it opens the door for other light industrial uses," a planning staff member said.


Staff said the lot was zoned light industrial before the Unified Development Code, was downzoned to Regional Center when the code was adopted, was rezoned back to light industrial in November 2024 for an import-export project that never happened, and was rezoned to R-3 in August 2025 for apartments that were not built either.


Commissioner Nurith Galonsky moved a middle path: zone the lot Regional Center with a specific use permit limited to the medical warehouse, with a site plan. Staff said the item will come back as a consent item. That motion was seconded and carried. The vote was announced as 6-0.


CARMAX, AN EVENT CENTER AND 112 DUPLEX LOTS


All of these are first readings:


  • CarMax. The commission approved a specific use permit for a CarMax used-car dealership on about 4.46 acres off Stillman Road in Oklahoma Station Subdivision No. 1. The agenda lists the acreage as approximately 4.461. Staff said "we received zero opposition to this request." Conditions include keeping all operations, loading and unloading inside the property, and parking vehicles only on concrete or asphalt. A CarMax representative from Lakewood, Colorado, spoke briefly in support. The vote count was not announced.

  • Texas Starway Street duplexes. All of Block 139, El Jardin Subdivision, goes from R-1 to R-2 for a duplex subdivision of about 112 lots. Staff said a solar-farm permit was approved on the land in May 2023 but never built. Subdivisions of 100 or more lots need at least three access points, which staff said would be worked out in platting. Announced vote: 5-0. Earlier coverage: A Solar Farm Was Approved Here. Now Brownsville Is Weighing 112 Duplex Lots Instead.

  • Event center at 1069 S. Expressway. The commission approved a specific use permit for an event center of about 3,230 square feet next to a planned beauty salon. Hours are 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Thursday for client meetings, and 7 p.m. to midnight Friday through Sunday. Staff said the site plan shows 43 parking spaces where 40 are required. Staff also said specific use permits "do not run with the land," and the old event center there lost its grandfathered status after sitting closed. A commissioner raised concerns about parking on a corner crowded with used-car lots. Announced vote: 6-0.

  • 2018 N. Minnesota Ave. Staff said the applicant agreed to change the request from R-3 to Corridor Commercial, so it fits the surrounding zoning, for a multifamily project on 0.84 acres. Announced vote: 7-0.

  • Towne North. A city-initiated rezoning from R-1 to R-2 for Lots 1 to 27, Block 1, on South Buckingham Court brings existing duplexes into compliance. Staff said single-family homes and accessory dwelling units are still allowed. Announced vote: 6-0.


WHERE THE MONEY WENT


The consent agenda passed in one motion, with item 7 pulled. The vote was announced as 7-0. Items in that motion included:


  • A custom-chassis pumper (Engine 9) for the Fire Department from Metro Fire Apparatus Specialists through Sourcewell, $1,347,160.

  • A five-year Westlaw and Clear legal-research agreement for the City Attorney's Office with West Publishing, not to exceed $245,395.44.

  • A five-year Cintas uniform lease and rental contract. The agenda prints the amount as "$375.000." The 956 Report has not confirmed the exact figure.

  • Change Order 2 with Decorative Concrete Design for the Planning Department renovation, $33,998, bringing that contract to $176,878.

  • Renewal of Vector Airport Systems' PlanePass landing-fee billing at the airport for three years, at 25% of landing fees collected. Also a $2,800 change order to Foremost Paving for runway 18-36 reconstruction.

  • An agreement with developer G&R Industrial Facilities LLC for a U.S. Economic Development Administration grant for the Marina Industrial Park.

  • Second and final readings of zoning code amendments regulating poker lounges, automotive quick-lube shops, event centers and self-storage facilities. Also second readings disannexing two tracts in the San Benito area (24170 U.S. Military Highway 281 and 26707 Rice Tract Road).

  • Cancellation of the Dec. 15, 2026 regular meeting.


Nell Palmer. Item 7, an engineering and surveying task order with Halff Associates for utility and road work along Nell Palmer, was approved separately. Lastra said the amount was reduced from $177,103 to $137,943 after the Public Utilities Board's portion was split out. He said the work is "100% city share," and the city will be reimbursed by property owners once the land is developed. The vote count was not announced.


PUBLIC COMMENT


The speakers covered during the meeting asked the city for more workshops and information about its trap-neuter-return services for stray cats downtown, a traffic study and speed hump on Duck Pond Drive in the Park View neighborhood, monthly park cleanups at the Brownsville Sports Park, and better sidewalks. Several said they were UTRGV students. One speaker criticized the commission's conduct in general terms and urged members not to run again.


During the City Manager's update, BARC presented its pet of the month, a one-month-old puppy named Mocha. A BARC staff member said, "At BARC the adoption fee is $25 but that does include the age appropriate vaccines, spay and neuter, microchipping as well." BARC reported 54 dogs and 40 cats adopted in October.


CLOSED-DOOR ITEMS


The commission met in executive session on seven listed items: two lawsuits (Cause Nos. 2026-DCL-03624 and 2026-DCL-06044-G), the Coffee Road Drainage Phase II parcel at 10 Draper Drive, Project Compass, the proclamation policy, Project Canvass, and legal matters tied to Project Gridline's application at the Public Utility Commission of Texas.


After returning, the commission voted to proceed "as discussed in executive session" on Cause No. 2026-DCL-03624. The vote was announced as 4-0. It took no action on the second lawsuit or the Coffee Road parcel. It also approved a motion to proceed as discussed on Project Compass. No terms, amounts or parties were stated in open session for any of these items.


City of Brownsville City Commission Meeting title card showing the domed tower of Brownsville City Hall - Old Federal Building.
Brownsville City Hall - Old Federal Building. Frame from the City of Brownsville's public meeting video.

WHO WAS THERE


Mayor John Cowen Jr. presided. The agenda lists Commissioners Tino Villarreal (At-Large A), Nurith Galonsky (At-Large B), Bryan L. Martinez (District 1), Linda C. Macias (District 2), Gustavo De Leon (District 3) and Pedro E. Cardenas (District 4). Martinez and Macias were noted as present shortly after the meeting started. Announced vote counts varied from item to item, from 7-0 to 4-0.


The commission honored Girl Scout Ambassador Alexandra Garcia for her Gold Award project on Parkinson's disease awareness, and recognized Veterans Day and the Veterans Day Wall. Through Resolution 2026-140, the commission filled a vacancy on the Brownsville Film Commission with the appointment made by Commissioner Villarreal. The appointee's name was stated as Daniel Salinas, and The 956 Report has not confirmed that spelling.


ANALYSIS


This section is analysis by The 956 Report.


The canvass is a legal step, but it starts the clock on real changes. Two of the new amendments, campaign finance (J) and the ethics code and board (K), direct the commission itself to write and pass ordinances. How quickly those come back to the dais is the next test. Proposition D's pay rates apply only to people first elected after the amendment takes effect, so no current member's pay changes because of it.


The Carlton Drive vote also shows how a recent change in state law plays out locally. Staff put the neighbors' opposition at 31% of the notice area. Under the old 20% threshold staff described, that would have triggered a supermajority requirement. Under the new 60% threshold, a simple majority was enough.


WHAT TO WATCH


  • Dec. 1: second and final reading of the canvass ordinance for the Brownsville charter amendments, and of the first-reading zoning cases above, including Carlton Drive.

  • How and when the commission writes the ordinances that several amendments call for, including campaign finance (J), the ethics code (K), and initiative and referendum (L, M).

  • The Carlton Drive ditch regrading the city engineer described, and any word from the Public Utilities Board on sewer capacity.

  • A Sam Perl Boulevard site plan and the revised Regional Center zoning with a specific use permit.


NEXT MEETING: WHAT'S ON THE AGENDA


The next City Commission regular meeting is Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2026, at 5 p.m. in the Commission Chambers at City Hall - Old Federal Building, 1001 E. Elizabeth St. The full agenda had not been posted as of Nov. 20. A posted notice lists a public hearing that night on Ordinance 2026-1835, which would annex about 400.92 acres at 9000 Ruben M. Torres Blvd. City staff also said at the meeting that a special meeting is planned for Dec. 8. Agenda items can change. Check the city's meeting portal: https://brownsvilletx.portal.civicclerk.com/event/1096/overview


WHAT WE COULDN'T CONFIRM


  • Proposition O was not read aloud at the meeting, and its official totals have not been confirmed by The 956 Report. Totals for Propositions H and N were not stated; the totals shown are The 956 Report's arithmetic.

  • Each member's vote on the 4-3 Carlton Drive motion, and the full roll call on the failed motion to deny, could not be confirmed from the meeting video.

  • Vote counts were not announced for CarMax, Nell Palmer, the Film Commission appointment or Project Compass.

  • The Cintas contract amount is printed as "$375.000" on the agenda.

  • The spelling of the Film Commission appointee's name has not been confirmed.

  • The second part of the meeting video begins partway through public comment, so this report does not cover every public comment speaker.


SOURCES


City of Brownsville, City Commission Meeting 11/17/2026 (meeting video, part 1)


City of Brownsville, City Commission Meeting 11/17/2026 - 2 (meeting video, part 2)


City of Brownsville, Agenda and packet, City Commission Canvassing and Regular Meeting, Nov. 17, 2026


City of Brownsville, Notice of Regular Meeting, Dec. 1, 2026 (Ordinance 2026-1835)


The Brownsville Herald, "Brownsville voters pass 15 propositions on ethics, commissioner pay, more," Nov. 9, 2026


Comments


bottom of page