CIMARRON'S NEW OWNERS WANTED A BOARD MEMBER GONE. TWENTY MINUTES LATER, SHE WAS OFF THE BOARD.
Updated: Nov 7
MISSION, Texas -- It took about twenty minutes on Tuesday, Oct. 27.
At 1:20 into the Mission City Council meeting, a representative of the new owners of Cimarron Country Club stepped to the podium with a printed statement and asked the council to remove a sitting member of the Cimarron Public Improvement District board.
At 1:42, the council voted unanimously to approve a resolution realigning that board. The resolution gives one of the five seats to the owners' group. The woman they had asked the council to remove was not in the new lineup.
No council member asked a single question before the vote.

This is the story of a five-person board that most Mission residents have never heard of. It may end up deciding how much Cimarron homeowners pay to restore a private country club, and on Tuesday its makeup was changed at the request of the club's new owners.
THE REQUEST
The speaker was Berenice Gonzalez, who said she represented the owners of "the new Cimarron Country Club," the investor group New Cimarron Group LLC.
She opened by saying the purchase was a private investment.

"Our decision to invest was never dependent on receiving public funding," Gonzalez told the council, "and our commitment to this project remains unchanged."
Then she added a qualifier.
"If there's any public improvement district funds available for improvements that benefit the community and our project, we are open to exploring that opportunity," she said, provided the project "meets all applicable requirements."
Then she turned to one board member.
"Unfortunately, our recent work experience with Miss Camarillo has been conflicting and disappointing," Gonzalez said, according to the meeting video. "There's been difficulties in communication and in obtaining and delivering clear and consistent information, along with the misrepresentation in her board position, that have undermined our confidence in the public improvement district process."
She did not give the council an example of any specific incident. She did not explain what "misrepresentation in her board position" referred to.
"As a result, we have stepped away from discussions concerning the public improvement district board while continuing to move forward with our redevelopment plans," she said. "For these reasons, we respectfully request that the city commission removes Miss Camarillo from the public improvement district board."
The board member is Ann Camarillo, a Cimarron homeowner and one of the PID's original board members, according to The Monitor, which also reported on the meeting.
Gonzalez then said something nobody on the dais had asked about.
"We also want to emphasize that our ownership group takes no position in support or opposition of any candidates in the city election," she said. "We are not about politics."
Mission's city election is one week away.

"I'VE NEVER SEEN OR HEARD OF IT"
Next came Joe Phillips, a longtime Cimarron property owner who sits on the PID board as one of its homeowner representatives. He said he was also speaking for fellow board member Dolly Elizondo.
Phillips backed the owners' request. He also said out loud how unusual the situation was.
"It's most extraordinary to support potentially the other side in discussion to have input into the makeup of our team," Phillips said. "It's just never heard of."
In other words, a homeowner representative told the council that the people across the negotiating table, the owners, were helping decide who sits on the residents' side. And he supported it anyway.
"In this case, we understand, Dolly and I understand the reasons," he said. "It's very unfortunate."
Phillips said the PID is important to the city, the new owners and the homeowners, but that talks were stalled.
"We can't even get started the discussions until there's been a change in the makeup," he said. "Basically, certain protocols were not followed. It's created issues."
He did not say which protocols.
"I've been on a lot of boards, a lot of boards," Phillips said, "and I frankly have never seen or heard of the kind of behavior that took place by one board member."
He did not describe what the behavior was.
THE VOTE
When the item came up, city staff told the council the PID board had met on Monday, Oct. 12, and passed a motion recommending that the council "re-evaluate and realign" its composition.
Under the new structure:
Place 1: Andrew Todd Gilliland (Cimarron neighborhood)
Place 2: Dolly Elizondo (Cimarron neighborhood)
Place 3: Joe Phillips (Cimarron neighborhood)
Place 4: Richard Castro, New Cimarron Group (golf course owner)
Place 5: The mayor or a designee (city)
The board is also now empowered to appoint its own officers.
The previous board included the mayor, the Mission Economic Development Corporation's board president, and three Cimarron HOA members: Phillips, Elizondo and Camarillo, according to The Monitor.
So two seats changed. The MEDC seat became an owner seat. Camarillo's seat went to Gilliland.
Mayor Norie Garza explained only one of those changes from the dais.
"This was something that needed to happen because the City of Mission was no longer an owner of the property," the mayor said. "So we needed to replace that position with the new owner."
That explains why the owners got a seat. It does not explain why Camarillo lost hers. No one on the council addressed that.
The legal document itself was not final when the council approved it. The city attorney said he had been negotiating the language with outside counsel he described as his "counterpart."
"The names don't change. It's just the legal technical language," he told the council. "I'm just working out two more kinks in there."
The council approved Resolution 2093 "subject to final legal review." The mayor asked whether there were any other questions or comments. There were none. The motion carried unanimously.
WHY THIS BOARD MATTERS
A public improvement district is not a social club. Under Chapter 372 of the Texas Local Government Code, a PID can recommend assessments, charges that appear on property owners' tax bills, to pay for improvements inside its boundaries. The city council keeps final approval over any assessment.
The Cimarron PID was created on March 24, 2025, covering roughly 366 acres of the Cimarron neighborhood, according to The Monitor.
From the start, the plan tied the PID to the golf course. When the city and its economic development corporation bought Cimarron in February 2025, the MEDC's own announcement said the PID, once created and funded by Cimarron residents, would work with the eventual buyer and help with improvements allowed under the law.
An estimated $20 million in improvements was floated at the time, according to the Progress Times. When the club was sold this summer, the deal required the buyer to make at least $10 million in improvements, according to the RGV Business Journal.
That is the tension at the center of this story. Gonzalez says the owners never needed public money. But the deal was designed from day one around a district that can assess homeowners, and the owners told the council they remain "open to exploring" those funds. Now they hold one of the five seats on the board that will help decide how those funds are used.
What did Camarillo do, or object to, that made her unacceptable to the owners? Nothing in the public record answers that. It is the most important unanswered question in this story.
THE ROUND TRIP: $5 MILLION OUT, $2.5 MILLION BACK
The Cimarron saga did not start with Tuesday's vote.
In February 2025, the City of Mission and the MEDC bought the shuttered country club from the Kamel family's Black Diamond Developers for $5 million, with each contributing $2.5 million, according to The Monitor.
In June 2026, the MEDC sold it to New Cimarron Group LLC, a group led by Mission native and professional golfer Abraham Ancer and backed by the Mexico-based investment group GDI FUSA, for $2.5 million, according to the MEDC and The Monitor. KRGV reported the price as "nearly $3 million." The closing documents should settle that.
Earlier this year, MEDC CEO Teclo Garcia said the sale proceeds would go back to the city "so the city will be made whole," according to The Monitor.
That accounts for the city's half. It does not account for the MEDC's $2.5 million, or for what was spent maintaining and repairing the property while the public owned it. MEDC money is public money, generated by Mission's sales tax.
According to The Monitor, members of the investment group also own homes in Cimarron. That would make them both the owners of the club and property owners inside the district.
THE COUNCILMAN WHO LIVES THERE
One more detail is worth noting.
Mayor Pro Tem Ruben Plata owns a home in Cimarron and signed the 2024 petition asking the city to create the PID, according to the Progress Times. When the council voted in March 2025 to establish the district and appoint its first board, Plata abstained, according to a published account of that meeting.
On Tuesday, when the city secretary called for disclosures of conflicts of interest at the start of the meeting, she answered: "We have none, mayor." The PID item passed unanimously, and the meeting record contains no abstention.
That doesn't establish wrongdoing. There may be a sound legal reason the circumstances differ this time. But it is a fair question for Plata and the city attorney: why abstain on the district's creation in 2025, but not on reshaping its board in 2026?
Tuesday was Plata's last regular meeting after 19 years on the council.
"The citizens are our bosses," he told the room.
The residents of Cimarron are the ones who could end up paying assessments. They deserve to know why one of their representatives was replaced, and on whose request.
Quotes from the Oct. 27, 2026, Mission City Council meeting are transcribed from the city's meeting video and lightly edited for clarity.
-- Joshua Moroles reports on the Rio Grande Valley for The 956 Report.
==================================================
PUBLISHING AND SEO PACKAGE
==================================================
Blog headline:
Cimarron's New Owners Wanted a Board Member Gone. Twenty Minutes Later, She Was Off the Board.
SEO title tag (under 60 characters):
Cimarron PID Shake-Up: Owners Wanted a Board Member Out
Meta description (approx. 155 characters):
Cimarron Country Club's new owners asked Mission to remove a PID board member. The council realigned the board unanimously, without a single question.
URL slug:
cimarron-pid-board-shakeup-mission-council
Excerpt:
Cimarron Country Club's new owners asked the Mission City Council to remove a homeowner from the district board that could help fund their restoration. Twenty minutes later, the council approved a new board with an owners' seat and without her.
Focus keywords:
Primary: Cimarron PID, Cimarron Country Club, Mission City Council
Secondary: public improvement district Mission Texas, Ann Camarillo, New Cimarron Group, Abraham Ancer Cimarron, Mission EDC Cimarron sale, Ruben Plata, Rio Grande Valley local news
==================================================
EDITOR'S NOTES -- NOT FOR PUBLICATION
==================================================
MUST DO BEFORE PUBLISHING
1. Contact Ann Camarillo for comment. Fill the placeholder. This is the single biggest legal and fairness item.
2. Contact Ruben Plata and the Mission city attorney on the abstention question. Fill the placeholder.
3. Contact Berenice Gonzalez / New Cimarron Group and Joe Phillips. Ask what the "misrepresentation" and the "protocols" were. Confirm Gonzalez's role (attorney, manager, or partner).
4. Verify every pull quote against the city's video. The source is an auto-generated transcript, and the quotes have been lightly cleaned. The phrases "Miss Camarillo" (the transcript says "Anamario") and "city commission" in particular need checking.
5. Confirm spellings against Resolution 2093: Gilliland, Elizondo, and Richard vs. Ricardo Castro.
6. Confirm the vote count on Item 27. The transcript and The Monitor say "unanimously" but don't record individual votes.
7. Verify Plata's March 2025 abstention against the official city minutes. The account used (citizenportal.ai) is AI-generated and is not a primary source.
8. If you'd rather not attribute the purchase split to The Monitor alone, confirm it in the MEDC FY25 audit. Texas Border Business reported the city funded the purchase, so the sources conflict.
9. Confirm whether Mayor Garza is on the Nov. 2026 ballot before adding anything that implies she is running.
LEGAL FLAGS (STAYED WITHIN)
- All characterizations of Camarillo are attributed to Gonzalez or Phillips at a public meeting, which is covered by Texas fair-report privilege (CPRC 73.002) when reported accurately and fairly. The story never states as fact that she did anything wrong.
- The story does not say the council "removed" Camarillo. It says the council approved a realignment and she was not in the new lineup. Change this only if the city confirms a removal.
- The theory that resident assessments could fund a private club is framed as the structural tension and an open question, not as anyone's motive.
- The Plata item is framed as a question, with an explicit "doesn't establish wrongdoing" line.
- The Salinas disclosure is included.
- Nothing in the piece targets Camarillo or anyone else with repeated contact or calls to action, so there is no Penal Code 42.06 exposure. Keep social posts about it the same way: no tagging her or urging people to contact her.
SOURCES
- City of Mission City Council meeting video/transcript, Oct. 27, 2026
- The Monitor, "Member's behavior prompts Cimarron PID board realignment," Oct. 30, 2026: https://myrgv.com/local-news/2026/10/30/members-behavior-prompts-cimarron-pid-board-realignment/
- The Monitor, Feb. 24, 2025 (purchase, $2.5M split): https://myrgv.com/publications/the-monitor/2025/02/24/mission-edc-purchase-cimarron-country-club-for-5-million/
- The Monitor, Feb. 5, 2026 (Garcia "made whole"): https://myrgv.com/local-news/2026/02/05/missions-economic-arm-has-super-great-hopes-for-2-5m-cimarron-sale/
- The Monitor, June 22, 2026 (sale, investors own Cimarron homes): https://myrgv.com/local-news/2026/06/22/mission-pro-golfer-abraham-ancer-agree-on-cimarron-sale/
- Mission EDC release (New Cimarron Group, GDI FUSA): https://www.missionedc.com/news-and-media/latest-news/p/item/68044/new-ownership-group-unveils-vision-for-historic-cimarron-country-club
- Mission EDC release, Feb. 2025 (PID to assist buyer): https://www.missionedc.com/news-and-media/latest-news/p/item/63740/mission-edc-city-of-mission-acquire-cimarron-club
- KRGV ("nearly $3 million"): https://www.krgv.com/news/mission-s-cimarron-country-club-sold-for-3-million
- RGV Business Journal ($10M improvement requirement): https://www.rgvbusinessjournal.com/news/19/06/2026/cimarron-county-club-acquired-by-investor-group-led-by-local-golf-pro-abraham-ancer/
- Progress Times, Jan. 31, 2025 (Plata petition, $20M estimate): https://www.progresstimes.net/2025/01/31/mission-seals-deal-to-buy-cimarron/
- Citizen Portal (Plata abstention, March 2025; verify against minutes): https://citizenportal.ai/articles/6108176/Texas/Hidalgo-County/Mission/Council-creates-Cimarron-public-improvement-district-and-appoints-five-member-board
- ValleyCentral (Salinas petition): https://www.valleycentral.com/news/local-news/cimarron-golf-course-now-a-neighborhood-nightmare/
- Alamo News Journal (Salinas, Phillips HOA fight): https://www.anjournal.com/news/cimarron-clubcourse-looks-dead




Comments